Polyhedron P is a cube with a corner removed and relocated to the top of the cube. Polyhedron Q is a cube with the same size base as Polyhedron P. How do their surface areas compare?
Polyhedron P’s surface area is less than Polyhedron Q’s surface area.
Polyhedron P’s surface area is equal to Polyhedron Q’s surface area.
Polyhedron P’s surface area is greater than Polyhedron Q’s surface area.
There is not enough information given to compare their surface areas.
Answer: Polyhedron P’s surface area is greater than Polyhedron Q’s surface area.
Students who select Choice A may think (or may just be guessing) that removing a piece of a solid always decreases its surface area. Students who select Choice B are correct that the large cube has the same surface area before and after the small cube is removed, but they are forgetting that putting the small cube back on top also contributes to the surface area. Students who select Choice D may not believe that the problem can be solved without specific measurements, such as a side length.